Can a U.S. Patent Application Proceed Without the Inventor’s Signature?
By Inki Kim, Patent Attorney, The Wave IP Law Firm
Greetings from The Wave IP Law Firm. In today’s column, patent attorney Inki Kim addresses a problem companies often face when filing a U.S. patent application. The time comes to ask an inventor to sign, but the inventor has already left the company, cannot be reached, or refuses to sign. Two questions often follow. “Can we still get a patent without the inventor’s signature?” and “If we never obtained the signature, does our company own the patent?”
The answers depend on which document the inventor was asked to sign. Two documents commonly signed in connection with a U.S. patent application serve different purposes. A patent may issue even if one of them is missing, while the question of ownership may remain unresolved. This column explains what inventors and executives need to know.
1. The inventor initially holds the right to the invention
Under U.S. patent law, the right to obtain a patent initially belongs to the individual who made the invention. For a company to establish ownership, it must be able to document how the rights passed from the inventor to the company. That history of ownership is called the chain of title.
Two documents are particularly important in U.S. patent practice.
Inventor’s declaration | Assignment | |
Legal basis | 37 C.F.R. § 1.63 | 35 U.S.C. § 261 |
Type of document | A procedural document filed with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) | A private agreement between the inventor and the company |
What it says | The inventor has reviewed the application and believes they are an original inventor or joint inventor of the claimed invention | The inventor transfers rights in the invention to the company |
What it does | Confirms inventorship | Transfers ownership |
In plain English, a declaration says, “I am an inventor of what this application claims.” An assignment says, “I transfer my rights in this invention to the company.” An oral agreement alone does not transfer ownership by assignment.
Before signing a declaration, the inventor must personally review the application, including the specification and claims. A knowingly false statement may be punishable under federal law (18 U.S.C. § 1001), so inventors should read the application before they sign.
2. The declaration can wait, but delay carries risks
If the applicant files an Application Data Sheet (ADS) containing the required information, it may defer filing the declaration until it pays the issue fee. A surcharge applies when the declaration is filed after the filing date. Under the fee schedule revised in January 2025, the surcharge was US$170 for a large entity, US$68 for a small entity, and US$34 for a micro entity. If the issue-fee deadline passes without a valid declaration or an acceptable substitute, the application will be abandoned.
The practical risk is that a company may assume it has plenty of time and discover, shortly before the deadline, that it cannot obtain the signature. If you anticipate difficulty reaching an inventor or securing their cooperation, consider your options early in the application process.
3. When the inventor cannot sign, the applicant may be able to file a substitute statement
Under 37 C.F.R. § 1.64, an applicant, such as a company, may file a substitute statement in place of an inventor’s declaration in four circumstances.
- The inventor has died.
- The inventor is legally incapacitated.
- The inventor cannot be found or reached after diligent efforts.
- The inventor is under an obligation to assign the invention but refuses to sign the declaration.
In practice, the two most common situations are an inventor who cannot be reached and an inventor who refuses to sign. In either case, keep records that establish what happened and support the stated grounds for using a substitute statement. Relevant materials include:
- Email correspondence, proof of mailing, tracking numbers, and a dated log of attempted calls.
- A substitute statement explaining why the inventor’s signature could not be obtained and identifying the relationship between the company and the inventor.
- Documents supporting the company’s claim to the invention, such as an employment agreement establishing the inventor’s obligation to assign it.
Even if you expect that obtaining a signature will be difficult, first send the request by email or post and retain a copy. If a dispute arises later, that record can help establish the efforts you made. A properly filed substitute statement satisfies the inventor’s declaration requirement, allowing examination to proceed and the patent to issue if the other requirements are met.
4. There is no equivalent “substitute assignment”
A substitute statement can take the place of an inventor’s declaration. There is no corresponding USPTO procedure for an applicant to execute a “substitute assignment” simply because the inventor is unavailable. An assignment transfers a property interest and requires an effective transfer by the rights holder. A company that cannot obtain an inventor’s signature therefore needs to address both prosecution and ownership.
Objective | Action |
|---|---|
Keep the application moving through examination and issuance | File a substitute statement if the applicable requirements are met. |
Establish the company’s ownership | Review the invention-assignment clause in the inventor’s employment agreement. If the agreement effected a transfer, record it with the USPTO. Where possible, obtain a confirmatory assignment. |
During examination, the USPTO generally does not adjudicate who owns the invention. A patent may therefore issue even though the company has no separate assignment and has relied on a substitute statement to satisfy the declaration requirement. Issuance alone does not establish the company’s title. If ownership is later disputed, the employment agreement may be critical evidence. Whether the agreement itself transferred ownership depends on its wording.
5. How a few words can determine ownership in Stanford v. Roche
Stanford v. Roche (2011) illustrates how the wording of an assignment clause can determine who owns an invention.
- When researcher Mark Holodniy joined Stanford University, he signed an agreement stating that he “agree[d] to assign” his rights in research inventions to the university.
- Later, while visiting Cetus, whose relevant business Roche subsequently acquired, he signed a visitor agreement stating that he “will assign and do[es] hereby assign” his rights in inventions arising from his work there.
- When Roche commercialized the technology, Stanford sued for patent infringement. The Federal Circuit concluded that Roche held an ownership interest and that Stanford lacked standing to pursue the suit without Roche.
The wording mattered because it determined when the transfer took effect. “Agree to assign” creates a promise to transfer rights in the future. Under that wording, the inventor retains the rights until a separate assignment is executed. “Hereby assign” can effect a present assignment of rights in a future invention, so that the rights pass automatically when an invention covered by the agreement comes into being. This can close the gap during which an inventor might leave the company or transfer rights elsewhere before signing a separate assignment.
The same issue can arise in collaborative research. If a partner institution’s agreement contains “hereby assign,” rights may pass to that institution before your company obtains an assignment.
The question the U.S. Supreme Court directly decided was whether the Bayh-Dole Act automatically vested the university with title to inventions arising from federally funded research. The distinction between the assignment language in the two agreements came from the Federal Circuit’s decision.
6. An omitted inventor can put the entire patent at risk in Fortress Iron v. Digger Specialties
A missing signature can have consequences beyond an ownership dispute. In Fortress Iron v. Digger Specialties, the omission of a joint inventor came to light after the patents had issued. Correcting inventorship through the court under 35 U.S.C. § 256 required giving the omitted inventor notice and an opportunity to be heard. The inventor could not be located, so that requirement could not be met. The court could not correct inventorship, and the patents were held invalid.
If a company loses touch with a former employee, it may be unable to correct an inventorship error years later. Keeping inventors’ contact details current can help preserve the company’s ability to protect its patents.
Five things to check now
- Review the assignment language in employment agreements. Check whether the clause uses present-assignment language such as “hereby assign” and whether its scope covers continuation, divisional, and continuation-in-part (CIP) applications.
- Record the relevant assignment document. If you cannot obtain a separate assignment, check whether the employment agreement itself transferred the rights. If it did, record it with the USPTO and address any missing declaration through the substitute-statement procedure.
- Keep a record of signature requests. Retain the emails, mailing records, and call logs that show when and how you asked the inventor to sign.
- Stay in touch with former inventors. Periodically update contact information for inventors who have left the company.
- Address signatures early with outside collaborators. Put assignment terms in place when development begins. Arrange for each inventor to sign the declaration once they have reviewed the application, including its claims.
The wording of a single document and the timing of a signature can shape the outcome of litigation years later. If you are preparing to file a U.S. patent application or already have a case in which an inventor’s signature is missing, seek professional advice while there is still time to act.
References
- Stanford University v. Roche Molecular Systems, Inc. — Wikipedia
- The Supreme Court Clarifies Invention Ownership Under Bayh-Dole — Perkins Coie
- Fortress Iron v. Digger Specialties Underscores Limits of Section 256 Relief for Correction — Saul Ewing
- Where’s Waldo? Inventorship Error Fatal When Omitted Coinventor Cannot Be Found — JD Supra
Originally published in Korean by The Wave IP Law Firm. Read the original column